Doornfontein Pt.2 (Norman House, I. H. Harris School, 96 End Street & Caledonian Hall)

On the very edge of old Doornfontein running North to South is End Street – so-called because that was literally where the town ended. What was to become Doornfontein on the right was then just grazing land. The top part of End Street running from the railway line right up to Saratoga and what we now know as Nugget Hill was known as End Park. It’s the triangular collection of blocks to the left of the yellow line and was granted freehold status on condition it was ‘used for purposes incidental to and connected with the amusement and recreation of the inhabitants of the town’. In 1894 is had 3 tennis courts. The bottom section is still a park today.

Just north of Beit Street across the road from Norman house was a flower park known as Doornfontein Park.

Doornfontein Park c1895
Doornfontein Park c1895 (Source: A Johannesburg Album)
Map showing End Street in yellow. The circle shows the position of the water reservoir just behind where Ponte now stands
Map showing End Street in yellow. The triangular blocks running next to the top end of End Street is the park (Source: Watershed Town)
Possibly the old caretakers house on End Park from 2010
Possibly the old caretakers house on End Park from 2010 (Source: Marc Latilla)

Norman House stood in End Street with its entrance on Davies Street. Some sources indicated that it was built by John Dale Lace. Others say Barney Barnato lived there in 1897 with John Dale Lace purchasing the mansion later. A report by the JDA says “The extant mansion called Norman House (Dale Lace House or Norman Nursing Home) opposite Doornfontein Park and adjacent to the Irene Church with its front entrance on End Street, was built in 1893 by the JCI for its founding member Barney Barnato. This later became the residence, albeit for a short while, of José and John Dale Lace.” The report is dated May 2005 and the home was demolished sometime between 2005 and 2013. It became the Norman Nursing Home and the Dale Lace House for senior citizens in the last few years of its life. 

During the Lace’s time in the house, it was regarded as the perfect upmarket Johannesburg home. It was said to have a bath, that at a touch of a button, would ‘slide into the bedroom for added convenience’. Mr Lace demonstrated this one day to a group of friends while his wife Josie Lace was still in the bath. The visitors were evidently impressed.

Norman House Doornfontein
Norman House in the early 1900s
Irene_norman house_1972
Norman House behind the new Irene Church 1972
site of norman House 2013
Site of Norman House from 2013 (Source: Google Earth)

Keeping on End Street Just across Beit Street is I. H. Harris Primary School which started out as the Jewish Government School. The original school was connected to the old Park Synagogue ‘Jewish School of Johannesburg’ on the corner of De Villiers and Joubert Street which was built in 1896 and opened on 14 July 1897 by the Chief Justice J. Kotze. It was a three-story building with a hall on the ground floor. By 1907, it had 500 pupils but was overcrowded with the building itself regularly condemned by engineering and health authorities. 

Jewish School De Villiers Street
Original Jewish School connected to Park synagogue in De Villiers Street (Source: JDAP)

The old school was sold after the servitude on the land was removed. Land was bought in End Street near the Doornfontein Station in 1913 (S. A. Jewish Chronicle 24 April 1914) with the school built the following year. The school continued to be run by Mr. Abrahams, who had come out from London under Lord Milner. It was only in 1925, when Mr. I. H. Harris succeeded Mr. Abrahams, that the name of the school changed. Harris arrived in Johannesburg in 1905 also under Lord Milner. Of interest is that Hebrew instruction was sporadic and by 1918, amounted to an hour a day. By the late 1920s, the school was a regular English medium primary school.

IH Harris school buildings
IH Harris school buildings 2015 (Source: Marc Latilla)
IH Harris school hall
IH Harris school hall 2015 (Source: Marc Latilla)
IH Harris school honours list
Jewish Government School Honours list (Source: Marc Latilla)
IH Harris school headmasters board
IH Harris school headmasters board 1902-1986 (Source: Marc Latilla)

On the opposite side of the track on End Street stood the Doornfontein (or End Street) Club, a men’s social club built by Sam Height in 1888. The club, which is reputed to have had a dining room that could seat 750, was too lavish and expensive and was soon sold to Mother Ambrose of the Order of the Holy Family who turned it into the End Street Convent. This was the precursor to the Parktown Convent which was completed in 1905. The site today, across from End Park, is a high-rise building that was once headquarters for Nedbank.

Doornfontein or End Street Club
Doornfontein or End Street club
Doornfontein convent
Doornfntein club as a convent early 1900s (Source: A Johannesburg Album)
Site of Doornfontein club and Convent 2017
Site of Doornfontein club and Convent 2017 (Source: Google Earth)

As the wealthy randlords moved north over the hill to the new and more exclusive suburb of Parktown in the late 1890s and early 1900s (Barney Barnato built Barnato Park in Berea and John Dale Lace built Northwards in Parktown), many of these Doornfontein mansions – being too big and expensive to own or run on a modest income – were torn down and the land subdivided on which new houses or buildings were erected to accommodate a larger middle-class population.

One such example is the Herbert Baker designed S.A. School of Music built in 1906 on what was the former tennis court of “leading businessman” Mr. Morris Rosenburg situated at 96 End Street. Its foundation stone was laid by Lady Farrar, wife of Sir George Farrar, on 26 January 1906. The building also served as a macaroni factory from 1926 before it was restored into the Adam Leslie Theatre in 1967. At one time, it was the only unplastered brick gable building in the Transvaal.

96 End Street from around late 1960s showing the gabled brick work
96 End Street from around late 1960s showing the gabled brickwork (Source: Herbert Baker in South Africa)
96 End Street in 2011
96 End Street in 2011 (Source: Marc Latilla)
96 End Street front elevation drawing
96 End Street front elevation drawing (Source: Between the Chains)

On 20 August 1976 it became MANDY’S – a nightclub that saw through 70s disco and the 80s HI-NRG eras. The original MANDY’S burnt down within a few months of opening (possibly by a competing club). It was soon re-opened under new management as the NEW MANDY’S, which is the MANDY’S most people know.

In 1986 it became IDOLS (with Larry Nathan manning the door RIP).

Original Mandys opening night flyer
Original Mandys opening night flyer (Source: Andrew Wood)
The other side of the flyer
The other side of the flyer (Source: Andrew Wood)
Mandy's Nightclub comp
‘New’ Mandy’s Nightclub comp (Source: Andrew Wood)
Vintage disco record with the Mandy's stamp
Vintage disco record with the Mandy’s stamp (Source: Marc Latilla)
'Ends' opened briefly between Mandys II and IDOLS
‘Ends’ opened briefly in November 1986 between Mandy’s and IDOLS (Source: Andrew wood)
IDOLS opened officially December 1986
IDOLS opened officially on 10 December 1986 (Source: Andrew Wood)
IDOLS comp
IDOLS comp (Source: Marc Latilla)
Idols Nightclub from the late 1980s
Idols Nightclub from the late 1980s (Source: Facebook collection)
Old Idols and Mandys from 2018
School of music from 2018 (Source: Yeshiel Panchia)

I went to Idols a couple of times in 1989/90. It was two blocks away from THE JUNCTION which was more my thing (and the club that would have a lasting impression on my music taste and DJ career). Sometime later in the 90s after IDOLS, it became another popular dance club called ESP. Again, a legendary place and famous for going on non-stop right through to Sunday night. All three clubs were icons of their respective scenes and are fondly remembered by all who went there. I have a 90-minute tape from one of the nights at IDOLS and a bunch of old disco records with the MANDY’S stamp like the example posted above. But I digress…

As of 2018, the building has been partially restored and turned into a crèche with two small businesses running out of the ground floor. The owner wants to rebuild the back-end in the future. The gabled brickwork has also been exposed for the first time in 40 years.

A stone’s throw from 96 End street stands Caledonian Hall

Caledonian Hall built in 1905 on the corner of Jeppe and End Street from 2011
Caledonian Hall built in 1905 on the corner of Jeppe and End Street from 2011 (Source: Marc Latilla)

It was formerly the headquarters of the Johannesburg Caledonian Society up until 1939. It’s foundation stone was laid by Caledonian Chief A. Dickson on September 2, 1905 and it’s said that every brick and stone of the castle-like building was brought over from Scotland. The building was in the Scottish Baronial style and was designed by Leck & Emley. It has served as an entertainment hall, catering establishment (Ginsberg Caterers), a warehouse, a carpet business and was also a popular nightclub in the late 80s or early 90s called Club Babylon which featured three floors all playing different music. I recall that it may have even been home to a club called IT in the mid-90s.

Early postcard of the Caledonian Club early 1900s
Early postcard of the Caledonian Club early 1900s (Source: A Johannesburg Album)
Caledonian Hall by Phiip Bawcombe
Caledonian Hall painting by Philip Bawcombe (Source: Johannesburg)

The building was unfortunately destroyed in a fire in March 2012. It stood up until 2014 as there was a possibility of a restoration. The facade was in an okay condition, but the roof was destroyed and the floors had all collapsed. As of 2015, what was left of the ruin has been completely demolished.

Doornfontein Caledonian demolish site 2015
Site of the Caledonian Hall in 2015 (Source: Marc Latilla)

Some general views of Doornfontein:

Early view of Doornfontein down Harrow road 1888
Early view of Doornfontein down Harrow road 1888 (Source: A Johannesburg Album)
View of Doornfontein from the water reservoir behind where Ponte now stands 1890
View of Doornfontein from the water reservoir behind where Ponte now stands 1890 (Source: Watershed Town)

The reservoir was built by the Johannesburg Waterworks Estate and Exploration Company in 1888 at the source of the Jukskei. The stream ran down what became Harrow Road and down to a marshy area (which later became Ellis Park Lake) where Ellis Park stadium is today. Then it meanders through Bertrams, Lorentzville, Judith’s Paarl, Bez Valley, Bruma, Observatory and down to Gillooly’s Farm where it goes left around the hill towards Alexandra Township and beyond. 

Ellis Park Lake early 1900s
Ellis Park Lake early 1900s looking East toward Bertrams and Judith’s Paarl (Source: A Johannesburg Album)
View looking South with Doornfontein in the background before Ponte was built. This is after Harrow Road was widened around late 1960s
View looking South with Doornfontein in the background before Ponte was built. This is after Harrow Road was widened around late 1960s (Source: Johannesburg Saga)
View of Doornfontein from 2011
View of New Doornfontein from 2011 (Source: Marc Latilla)

Special thanks to Andrew Wood for the old comps. He has scanned and shared many old comps, flyers and club-related newspaper articles from the 70s and 80s from his extensive collection.

© 2011 Johannesburg 1912. Please don’t copy our content or images without permission — we work hard to research and produce everything you read here. If you’d like to share something, please link back to the original post. Thank you for respecting our work.

Reference:

Katz, M. E. 1980. The History of Jewish Education in South Africa 1841-1980. University of Cape Town. Doctor of Philosophy in Education  

Doucakis, A, 1991. Southern New Doornfontein & environs-An historical survey part II. Between the Chains, Vol.12

Johannesburg Historical Foundation, undated. Some Historic Drives & Walks of Johannesburg. Written and produced by the JHF

Bawcombe, P, 1973. Johannesburg. Johannesburg: Village Publishing

Norwich, O. I, 1986. A Johannesburg album-Historical postcards. Johannesburg: AD. Donker

—. 1986. The Mervyn King Ridge Trail. Johannesburg: Johannesburg City Council

—, 14 April 1974. Sunday Times magazine. 

Bawcombe, P, 1973. Johannesburg. Johannesburg: Village Publishing (text by Ted Scannell)

Norwich, O, undated. Historic description of Beit Street from End Street to Siemert Road in Doornfontein as a conservation area. Johannesburg Historical Foundation booklet 

Updates:

Added I. H. Harris Primary School and End Street Club/Convent info and photos: 2 September 2018

Corrected source of Ellis Park Lake (Jukskei, not Natal Spruit): 6 September 2018


Discover more from Johannesburg 1912 – suburb by suburb research

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

13 responses to “Doornfontein Pt.2 (Norman House, I. H. Harris School, 96 End Street & Caledonian Hall)”

  1. I work in the clubbing industry. I’m also a part-time tourist guide, so invaluable info! Luvly!

  2. […] The first Congregational services were held in a wood & iron structure in Von Brandis square by Rev. F. J. Ecclestone. The church then moved to Richard Currie’s auction rooms in Commissioner Street on the 25th April 1899 and later to the Masonic Hall in Jeppe Street before their new church was finally ready for occupation in late 1895. Ten years later in 1905 it was joined by the Sir Herbert Baker designed School of Music across the road in End Street and the Caledonian Club which was built behind it. In 1913 on organ chamber was added. Where the church once stood is now a nondescript building. The Caledonian Club burnt down a few years ago and has now also been demolished. Further info on the School of Music and Caledonian Club can be found here. […]

  3. […] Adam Leslie Theatre opened on the 27 August 1967 at 96 End Street. The Herbert Baker designed building was built in 1906 and was originally the College of Music. Up until Adam Leslie took it over it had also been used as a macaroni factory and a boot factory. Adam restored it to its former glory down to the interior and furnishings. The chandelier was from an original randlords mansion. The theatre opened with ‘Music Hall Revue’ starring Adam Leslie and Joan Blake and was directed by Anthony Farmer. In the late 70s it became Mandys Nightclub followed by Idols in the late 80s and finally ESP in the 90s. All were groundbreaking and succesful clubs in their time. The building is sadly in a state of disrepair and probably not able to be restored. I’ve written a more in-depth piece on this majestic and historical building here […]

  4. […] of Theatres, History of Trams, Doornfontein Pt.2 (presumably for the info on the old clubs MANDYS, Idols and ESP), Hillbrow Pt.1 and Lost […]

  5. Love what you are doing. 96 End street was my weekend home from 1989 – 1996/ish. I didn’t experience Mandy’s, but at Idols I was one of the cool kids and at ESP I was too off my face to give a shit.
    What I really love though is the history of it all. Beautiful building and beautiful city!

    1. Thanks Ian! I never experienced ESP…only Idols a few times. Admittedly, I was a bit young

  6. im very proud of ih harris build by the jewish community

  7. Thanks for the story’s & pics. I was part of the scene having opened a number of clubs.Chelsea Theatre where I launched some great bands such as Ella Mental, Bright Blue, Petite Cheval, Mapensula & others then King of Clubs Softies, Cherry Faced Lurchers…..,Junction, Decodance, Sneaky Petes and my favorite for a short period was the Caledonian where I had a few memorable events. I was forced out by some heavy gangster who owned the Romance… but that was JHB & we all had to live thru the politics & lawlessness of the time.I have a large collection of photos & posters which I hope will survive after I’m gone. They are collecting dust in a storage in George.

    1. Thanks Shayne! I’ll be going through the document you sent me on the Durban club scene over the next few days. Hopefully, we can get together in the new year so I can tap all your valuable knowledge!

  8. Dean Pavlovic Avatar
    Dean Pavlovic

    I was going to that school 1973 great memories.

  9. I came across your webb page by accident and very much enjoyed reading about “Old Doornfontein” where I grew up. I would like to point out that the name change from Jewish Government to I. H. Harris happened in the mid to late sixties and not in 1925. I attended Jewish Government until 1965 and then went to Athlone Boys High. My farther was on the parents teachers committee and from memory believe that he was involved in changing the name as at that stage there were very few Jewish children in the school. I happen to be in contact with two other pupils who were with me at the time.

    Thank you for an extremely interesting history.

    1. Thanks Rodney! Let me check my source on that. I recall thinking at the time that it was very early for the name change

  10. […] Marc Latilla does a great job keeping Joburg’s history alive. Here’s a great post on Idols – and Mandys – Nightclub. https://johannesburg1912.com/2011/04/28/doornfontein-part2/ […]

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.